RSS Feed

Google Chrome – Shiny, but not there yet

3 September, 2008 3:01 pm by Geoff

Googles new browser - Chrome

Google's new browser - "Chrome"

Google have released a new internet browser out into the wild : “Google Chrome” – to compete with Internet Explorer and Mozilla Firefox. There’s a little bit of confusion around exactly why Google would want to do that given that they are deeply involved with Mozilla Firefox: both in developers and cash, but it starts making sense once you use it. This browser is fast. And it’s especially fast for applications with a lot of Javascript – GMail, Google Docs, Google Maps, etc. It has a shiny new Javascript virtual machine running under the hood, and it works a treat. Beautiful.

So, here’s the Geoff wrap up in a few short points:

Why You Would Use It

  • Makes fantastic use of screen real estate – barely takes up any room at all which means you’ve got tons of room on the screen for the stuff you actually care about.  More stuff fits on your screen, which means you have to scroll less, which makes the world a happier place
  • Freaking fast – I’ve said it already but this canes the buttocks off either of the big two browsers just in terms of speed.
  • Default Home Page – Every time you open a new tab in Chrome, instead of a blank screen, the page shows a grid of your most visited sites that are accessible with the click of a mouse. Because this is driven completely locally, you’re not waiting for the homepage to load up over a slow connection – it just works. Sure it’s probably stolen from Opera, but it’s a good idea
  • It’s Google – and they make good stuff. The big positive about Google is that they have a philosophy of “release early then iterate”, meaning that the failures of today will likely not be there tomorrow.

Why You Wouldn’t Use It (at least all the time)

  • No RSS Support – now I realise that this might not mean a lot for some of you, but there are a bunch of us that this will raise alarm bells for. Not only do you not get the cute little feed icon showing up in the address bar of a relevant site, but if you click on an RSS feed link, you just get garbled junk.
  • Missing features – because it’s early days, there are a few features that are easy to get used to in Firefox that feel missing in Chrome. Ironically for a Google product, Chrome doesn’t have a search bar, but instead has you typing search queries into the address bar, which seems to me to be a little counter-intuitive. Maybe I just need to get over it
  • No extensions – For a long time Firefox user, this is a bit of a sad one. Extensions are pluggable bits of code that magically do fun (or useful) things to your browser to add functionality. At this stage there’s nothing like that for Chrome, and while I think that’ll change, for the moment that’s a deal killer.
  • It’s only on Windows at the moment, which means people who have a choice about their OS are unlikely to be able to use it yet.
  • You might still be stuck in the Internet Explorer world where you didn’t realise you had a “web browser” other than the big blue e.
So for the moment, it won’t be my primary browser of choice. Although I could actually imagine that if I was doing anything significant in Google Docs for example, I’d be a fair chance to fire this one up. The real key will be seeing how Google continue to develop this one, and whether the reasons not to use it really do disappear overnight.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

4 Comments

  1. Jermayn says:

    I also downloaded it and tested it and while I agree with your points, I think it has heaps to go until I would use it over firefox..

  2. George Toms says:

    Google Chrome is really fast!
    Now I can sort 200,000 records inside of Browser (Chrome) just in 1 sec. (Faster than Microsoft Excel):
    http://www.ardentedge.com/ex_if.htm

  3. Chrome will be able to compete in more decent terms than Firefox was ever to do against IE.
    Chrome rules, it is like Firefox, but with better minds behind. I hope FF disappears and every effort is set up to continue the good line of Chrome.

  4. [...] – bookmarked by 4 members originally found by turen007 on 2008-10-10 Google Chrome – Shiny, but not there yet http://www.geoffreport.com/wp/2008/09/03/google-chrome-great-but-not-there-yet/ – bookmarked by 1 [...]

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.